Why doesn't Shulchan Aruch include the laws of destroying fruit trees?Pesach/Passover Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara Planned maintenance scheduled April 23, 2019 at 23:30UTC (7:30pm US/Eastern) Best Answer Contest winners! Second quarter of 5779 To celebrate Mi Yodeya's tenth birthday, let's divide and conquer the entire…Anonymous glosses in the Shulchan AruchWhy do we make a blessing on the blossoming of fruit trees (birkat hailanot)?Why is the Shulchan Aruch definitive?Why is there such fervor to say the blessing on blossoming fruit trees?Who authored the topic - division headings in the Shulchan Aruch?Why isn't maakeh in the Tur?5th part of the shulchan aruchWhat is the Shulchan Aruch Ha'Arizal?Consistent philosophy in the Shulchan AruchLearning to translate the Shulchan Aruch

How to compare two different files line by line in unix?

The Nth Gryphon Number

Is multiple magic items in one inherently imbalanced?

Would it be easier to apply for a UK visa if there is a host family to sponsor for you in going there?

What is the difference between a "ranged attack" and a "ranged weapon attack"?

How does the math work when buying airline miles?

Why do early math courses focus on the cross sections of a cone and not on other 3D objects?

If Windows 7 doesn't support WSL, then what is "Subsystem for UNIX-based Applications"?

Co-worker has annoying ringtone

An adverb for when you're not exaggerating

How does a spellshard spellbook work?

Sliceness of knots

What is the meaning of 'breadth' in breadth first search?

How to report t statistic from R

Did Mueller's report provide an evidentiary basis for the claim of Russian govt election interference via social media?

Crossing US/Canada Border for less than 24 hours

How does light 'choose' between wave and particle behaviour?

Should a wizard buy fine inks every time he want to copy spells into his spellbook?

Why we try to capture variability?

Why can't I install Tomboy in Ubuntu Mate 19.04?

What does 丫 mean? 丫是什么意思?

Electrolysis of water: Which equations to use? (IB Chem)

Why is it faster to reheat something than it is to cook it?

Strange behavior of Object.defineProperty() in JavaScript



Why doesn't Shulchan Aruch include the laws of destroying fruit trees?



Pesach/Passover
Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara
Planned maintenance scheduled April 23, 2019 at 23:30UTC (7:30pm US/Eastern)
Best Answer Contest winners! Second quarter of 5779
To celebrate Mi Yodeya's tenth birthday, let's divide and conquer the entire…Anonymous glosses in the Shulchan AruchWhy do we make a blessing on the blossoming of fruit trees (birkat hailanot)?Why is the Shulchan Aruch definitive?Why is there such fervor to say the blessing on blossoming fruit trees?Who authored the topic - division headings in the Shulchan Aruch?Why isn't maakeh in the Tur?5th part of the shulchan aruchWhat is the Shulchan Aruch Ha'Arizal?Consistent philosophy in the Shulchan AruchLearning to translate the Shulchan Aruch










5















Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)










share|improve this question



















  • 2





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA
    Apr 1 at 20:23






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    Apr 1 at 20:48















5















Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)










share|improve this question



















  • 2





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA
    Apr 1 at 20:23






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    Apr 1 at 20:48













5












5








5








Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)










share|improve this question
















Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)







halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Apr 1 at 20:49







רבות מחשבות

















asked Apr 1 at 20:17









רבות מחשבותרבות מחשבות

14.7k131124




14.7k131124







  • 2





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA
    Apr 1 at 20:23






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    Apr 1 at 20:48












  • 2





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA
    Apr 1 at 20:23






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    Apr 1 at 20:48







2




2





It's not the only thing missing

– Double AA
Apr 1 at 20:23





It's not the only thing missing

– Double AA
Apr 1 at 20:23




2




2





@DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

– רבות מחשבות
Apr 1 at 20:48





@DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

– רבות מחשבות
Apr 1 at 20:48










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















5














R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







share|improve this answer


















  • 1





    Thanks, nice find, but the answer isn't very compelling. There are a significant enough number of halachos associated with this that would lead us to expect psak.

    – רבות מחשבות
    Apr 2 at 0:42


















1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









5














R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







share|improve this answer


















  • 1





    Thanks, nice find, but the answer isn't very compelling. There are a significant enough number of halachos associated with this that would lead us to expect psak.

    – רבות מחשבות
    Apr 2 at 0:42















5














R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







share|improve this answer


















  • 1





    Thanks, nice find, but the answer isn't very compelling. There are a significant enough number of halachos associated with this that would lead us to expect psak.

    – רבות מחשבות
    Apr 2 at 0:42













5












5








5







R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







share|improve this answer













R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.








share|improve this answer












share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer










answered Apr 1 at 21:02









AlexAlex

24.1k157136




24.1k157136







  • 1





    Thanks, nice find, but the answer isn't very compelling. There are a significant enough number of halachos associated with this that would lead us to expect psak.

    – רבות מחשבות
    Apr 2 at 0:42












  • 1





    Thanks, nice find, but the answer isn't very compelling. There are a significant enough number of halachos associated with this that would lead us to expect psak.

    – רבות מחשבות
    Apr 2 at 0:42







1




1





Thanks, nice find, but the answer isn't very compelling. There are a significant enough number of halachos associated with this that would lead us to expect psak.

– רבות מחשבות
Apr 2 at 0:42





Thanks, nice find, but the answer isn't very compelling. There are a significant enough number of halachos associated with this that would lead us to expect psak.

– רבות מחשבות
Apr 2 at 0:42



Popular posts from this blog

Triangular numbers and gcdProving sum of a set is $0 pmod n$ if $n$ is odd, or $fracn2 pmod n$ if $n$ is even?Is greatest common divisor of two numbers really their smallest linear combination?GCD, LCM RelationshipProve a set of nonnegative integers with greatest common divisor 1 and closed under addition has all but finite many nonnegative integers.all pairs of a and b in an equation containing gcdTriangular Numbers Modulo $k$ - Hit All Values?Understanding the Existence and Uniqueness of the GCDGCD and LCM with logical symbolsThe greatest common divisor of two positive integers less than 100 is equal to 3. Their least common multiple is twelve times one of the integers.Suppose that for all integers $x$, $x|a$ and $x|b$ if and only if $x|c$. Then $c = gcd(a,b)$Which is the gcd of 2 numbers which are multiplied and the result is 600000?

Србија Садржај Етимологија Географија Историја Политички систем и уставно-правно уређење Становништво Привреда Образовање Култура Спорт Државни празници Галерија Напомене Референце Литература Спољашње везе Мени за навигацију44°48′N 20°28′E / 44.800° СГШ; 20.467° ИГД / 44.800; 20.46744°48′N 20°28′E / 44.800° СГШ; 20.467° ИГД / 44.800; 20.467ууРезултати пописа 2011. према старости и полуу„Положај, рељеф и клима”„Europe: Serbia”„Основни подаци”„Gross domestic product based on purchasing-power-parity (PPP) valuation of country GDP”„Human Development Report 2018 – "Human Development Indices and Indicators 6”„Устав Републике Србије”Правопис српскога језикаGoogle DriveComparative Hungarian Cultural StudiesCalcium and Magnesium in Groundwater: Occurrence and Significance for Human Health„UNSD — Methodology”„Процене становништва | Републички завод за статистику Србије”The Age of Nepotism: Travel Journals and Observations from the Balkans During the Depression„The Serbian Revolution and the Serbian State”„Устав Србије”„Serbia a few steps away from concluding WTO accession negotiations”„A credible enlargement perspective for and enhanced EU engagement with the Western Balkans”„Freedom in the World 2017”„Serbia: On the Way to EU Accession”„Human Development Indices and Indicators: 2018 Statistical Update”„2018 Social Progress Index”„Global Peace Index”Sabres of Two Easts: An Untold History of Muslims in Eastern Europe, Their Friends and Foes„Пројекат Растко—Лузица”„Serbia: Introduction”„Serbia”оригинала„The World Factbook: Serbia”„The World Factbook: Kosovo”„Border Police Department”„Uredba o kontroli prelaska administrativne linije prema Autonomnoj pokrajini Kosovo i Metohija”оригиналаIvana Carevic, Velimir Jovanovic, STRATIGRAPHIC-STRUCTURAL CHARACTERISTICS OF MAČVA BASIN, UDC 911.2:551.7(497.11), pp. 1Archived„About the Carpathians – Carpathian Heritage Society”оригинала„O Srbiji”оригинала„Статистички годишњак Србије, 2009: Географски прегледГеографија за осми разред основне школе„Отворена, електронска база едукационих радова”„Влада Републике Србије: Положај, рељеф и клима”„Копрен (Стара планина)”„Туристичка дестинација-Србија”„Висина водопада”„РХМЗ — Републички Хидрометеоролошки завод Србије Кнеза Вишеслава 66 Београд”„Фауна Србије”„Српске шуме на издисају”„Lepih šest odsto Srbije”„Илустрована историја Срба — Увод”„Винчанска култура - Градска општина Гроцка”„''„Винча — Праисторијска метропола”''”оригиналаЈужни Словени под византијском влашћу (600—1025)Држава маћедонских Словена„Карађорђе истина и мит, Проф. др Радош Љушић, Вечерње новости, фељтон, 18 наставака, 24. август - 10. септембар 2003.”„Политика: Како је утврђена војна неутралност, 13. јануар. 2010, приступљено децембра 2012.”„Србија и РС оживеле Дејтонски споразум”„Са српским пасошем у 104 земље”Војска Србије | О Војсци | Војска Србије — Улога, намена и задациАрхивираноВојска Србије | ОрганизацијаАрхивираноОдлука о изради Стратегије просторног развоја Републике Србије до 2020. годинеЗакон о територијалној организацији Републике СрбијеЗакон о државној управиНајчешће постављана питања.„Смањење броја статистичких региона кроз измене Закона о регионалном развоју”„2011 Human development Report”„Službena upotreba jezika i pisama”„Попис становништва, домаћинстава и станова 2011. године у Републици Србији. Књига 4: Вероисповест, матерњи језик и национална припадност”„Вероисповест, матерњи језик и национална”„Специјална известитељка УН за слободу религије и вероисповести Асма Јахангир, код Заштитника грађана Саше Јанковића”„Закон о државним и другим празницима у Републици Србији”„Веронаука у српским школама”„Serbia – Ancestral Genography Atlas”Бела књига Милошевићеве владавинеоригиналаGross domestic product based on purchasing-power-parity (PPP) per capita GDP БДП 2007—2013Актуелни показатељи — Република Србија„Попис становништва, домаћинстава и станова 2011. године у Републици Србији Књига 7: Економска активност”Zemlje kandidati za članstvo u EU„Putin drops South Stream gas pipeline to EU, courts Turkey”„„Соко — историјат””оригинала„„Рембас — историјат””оригинала„„Лубница — историјат””оригинала„„Штаваљ — Историјат””оригинала„„Боговина — историјат””оригинала„„Јасеновац — историјат””оригинала„„Вршка чука — историјат””оригинала„„Ибарски рудници — историјат””оригинала„Закон о просторном плану Републике Србије од 2010 до 2020”„Кривични законик — Недозвољена изградња нуклеарних постројења, члан 267”„Б92: Srbija uklonila obogaćeni uranijum, 25. октобар 2011”„Коришћење енергије ветра у Србији — природни услови и практична примена”„Енергија ветра”„Србија може да прави струју од сунца, биомасе, воде и ветра”„Моја електрана и друге ветрењаче”„Биомаса, струја без инвестиција”„Auto-karte Srbije”„www.srbija.gov.rs Статистике о Србији”оригинала„Статистика зе месец децембар и 2016. годину”„Turizam u Srbiji”„Univerzitet u Beogradu: Vek i po akademskog znanja”„Vojnomedicinska akademija: 165 godina tradicije i napretka”Никола Гиљен, Соња Јовићевић Јов и Јелена Мандић: Мирослављево јеванђеље; Текст је публикован у ревији „Историја” и настао је као део научно-истраживачког рада Фонда „Принцеза Оливера”„World music асоцијација Србије”оригинала„World music у Србији”оригинала„Pogledajte: Boban Marković svira u redakciji „Blica”!”„Eurovision Song Contest 2007 Final”„Projekat Rastko, Alojz Ujes: Joakim Vujic”„Унеско”„Списак локалитета Светске баштине”„Guča i Egzit zaludeli svet”оригинала„Sabor trubača GUČA”„Interesting facts about Exit”оригинала„FIFA Association Information”„Serbia women win EuroBasket title, gain first Olympics berth”„Odbojkašice ispisale istoriju – Srbija je svetski prvak!”„Сајт Ватерполо савеза Србије, Освојене медаље”„Сајт ФК Црвена звезда, Бари”„Сајт ФК Црвена звезда, Токио”„Blic:Zlatna Milica! Mandićeva donela Srbiji najsjajnije odličje u Londonu!”„Милица Мандић освојила златну медаљу („Политика”, 12. август 2012)”„Златни Давор Штефанек”„DŽUDO ŠAMPIONAT Majdov osvojio svetsko zlato”„Španovićeva trećim skokom svih vremena do zlata!”„Чудо Иване Шпановић — 7,24 м („Политика”, 5. март 2017)”The Age of Nepotism: Travel Journals and Observations from the Balkans During the DepressionCalcium and Magnesium in Groundwater: Occurrence and Significance for Human HealthComparative Hungarian Cultural StudiesБела књига Милошевићеве владавинеоригиналаComparative Hungarian Cultural StudiesSabres of Two Easts: An Untold History of Muslims in Eastern Europe, Their Friends and FoesГеографија за осми разред основне школеSerbia: the country, people, life, customsМедијиВодичПодациВлада Републике СрбијеНародна скупштина Републике СрбијеНародна канцеларија председника Републике СрбијеНародна банка СрбијеТуристичка организација СрбијеПортал еУправе Републике СрбијеРепубличко јавно правобранилаштвоууууууWorldCat151202876n851959190000 0000 9526 67094054598-24101000570825ge130919

Barbados Ynhâld Skiednis | Geografy | Demografy | Navigaasjemenu