Alternating series test question.Offset Alternating SeriesLeibniz's alternating series testConfused about using alternating test, ratio test, and root test (please help).Shouldn't All Alternating Series Diverge?Shouldn't all alternating series diverge by the diverge test?Alternating series test and divergence test similair?Contradictions between the Alternating Series Test & Divergence Test?Alternating Series Test ConditionConvergence of series: $logleft(1 + frac1nsqrtnright )$Series: Alt. Series Test vs. Ratio Test. What is the point of converges absolutely?
How is it possible for user's password to be changed after storage was encrypted? (on OS X, Android)
Shall I use personal or official e-mail account when registering to external websites for work purpose?
Does bootstrapped regression allow for inference?
When blogging recipes, how can I support both readers who want the narrative/journey and ones who want the printer-friendly recipe?
Crop image to path created in TikZ?
Is a vector space a subspace?
Ideas for 3rd eye abilities
How to make particles emit from certain parts of a 3D object?
What to wear for invited talk in Canada
Information to fellow intern about hiring?
Why did the Germans forbid the possession of pet pigeons in Rostov-on-Don in 1941?
Is ipsum/ipsa/ipse a third person pronoun, or can it serve other functions?
Pristine Bit Checking
Where else does the Shulchan Aruch quote an authority by name?
New order #4: World
How can I fix this gap between bookcases I made?
If a centaur druid Wild Shapes into a Giant Elk, do their Charge features stack?
Is it legal to have the "// (c) 2019 John Smith" header in all files when there are hundreds of contributors?
What does "enim et" mean?
Why do UK politicians seemingly ignore opinion polls on Brexit?
Can the Produce Flame cantrip be used to grapple, or as an unarmed strike, in the right circumstances?
What happens when a metallic dragon and a chromatic dragon mate?
How to move the player while also allowing forces to affect it
What are the advantages and disadvantages of running one shots compared to campaigns?
Alternating series test question.
Offset Alternating SeriesLeibniz's alternating series testConfused about using alternating test, ratio test, and root test (please help).Shouldn't All Alternating Series Diverge?Shouldn't all alternating series diverge by the diverge test?Alternating series test and divergence test similair?Contradictions between the Alternating Series Test & Divergence Test?Alternating Series Test ConditionConvergence of series: $logleft(1 + frac1nsqrtnright )$Series: Alt. Series Test vs. Ratio Test. What is the point of converges absolutely?
$begingroup$
I'm reading this in my text:
So the alternating series test says:
i) is about the sequence decreasing
ii) is about the limit of the b term going to 0
I'm confused about why we need to do anything more once we find out that ii) isn't satisfied in example 2. What does it mean that we're looking at the limit of the nth term of the series? Don't we know that it diverges already? Also, can someone show me how they determine the limit of $a_n$?
sequences-and-series
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
I'm reading this in my text:
So the alternating series test says:
i) is about the sequence decreasing
ii) is about the limit of the b term going to 0
I'm confused about why we need to do anything more once we find out that ii) isn't satisfied in example 2. What does it mean that we're looking at the limit of the nth term of the series? Don't we know that it diverges already? Also, can someone show me how they determine the limit of $a_n$?
sequences-and-series
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
ii) fails to hold means that the alternating series test can't conclude if the series converges. You need to find a different test to check convergence.
$endgroup$
– tangentbundle
Mar 30 at 3:57
add a comment |
$begingroup$
I'm reading this in my text:
So the alternating series test says:
i) is about the sequence decreasing
ii) is about the limit of the b term going to 0
I'm confused about why we need to do anything more once we find out that ii) isn't satisfied in example 2. What does it mean that we're looking at the limit of the nth term of the series? Don't we know that it diverges already? Also, can someone show me how they determine the limit of $a_n$?
sequences-and-series
$endgroup$
I'm reading this in my text:
So the alternating series test says:
i) is about the sequence decreasing
ii) is about the limit of the b term going to 0
I'm confused about why we need to do anything more once we find out that ii) isn't satisfied in example 2. What does it mean that we're looking at the limit of the nth term of the series? Don't we know that it diverges already? Also, can someone show me how they determine the limit of $a_n$?
sequences-and-series
sequences-and-series
asked Mar 30 at 3:46
Jwan622Jwan622
2,35211632
2,35211632
$begingroup$
ii) fails to hold means that the alternating series test can't conclude if the series converges. You need to find a different test to check convergence.
$endgroup$
– tangentbundle
Mar 30 at 3:57
add a comment |
$begingroup$
ii) fails to hold means that the alternating series test can't conclude if the series converges. You need to find a different test to check convergence.
$endgroup$
– tangentbundle
Mar 30 at 3:57
$begingroup$
ii) fails to hold means that the alternating series test can't conclude if the series converges. You need to find a different test to check convergence.
$endgroup$
– tangentbundle
Mar 30 at 3:57
$begingroup$
ii) fails to hold means that the alternating series test can't conclude if the series converges. You need to find a different test to check convergence.
$endgroup$
– tangentbundle
Mar 30 at 3:57
add a comment |
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
Answer to First Question: So, notice that the summand in example 2 has the form
$$(-1)^n b_n = (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
where, clearly, $b_n = frac3n4n-1$. This sequence $b_n = frac3n4n-1$ is the one we must consider in the second condition for the alternating series test.
One condition that we have to check in order to use the alternating series test is that
$$lim b_n = 0$$
However, as the author pointed out,
$$lim b_n = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34 neq 0$$
Therefore, we cannot use the alternating series test to conclude anything; we have to try something else.
Answer to Question 2: To consider the $n$th term of the series means taking an arbitrary term in the series which has the form $(-1)^n frac3n4n-1$. Notice that this includes the $(-1)^n$, as opposed to just the $frac3n4n-1$. We then take
$$lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
Answer to Question 3: It should be clear this sequence $big(-1)^n frac3n4n-1big$ diverges due to oscillation, but we can be a bit more explicit. If the sequence converged, then if we consider the subsequences when $n$ is odd and $n$ is even, they should converge to the same limit.
However, if $n$ is even, then
$$n text even implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34$$
and if $n$ is odd,
$$n text odd implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim - frac3n4n-1 = - frac34$$
Therefore, since these two subsequences do not converge to the same value, it must be that the sequence $big(-1)^nfrac3n4n-1big$ diverges. Hence, by the divergence test, the series in question diverges.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Could you give an example of convergent series with $lim_ntoinfty|a_n|ne0$?
$endgroup$
– user
Mar 31 at 19:57
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Your confusion is justified.
From the definition of alternating series $sum_n=1^infty a_n$:
$$
a_n=(-1)^nb_n,quad b_n>0,
$$
it follows that $|a_n|=b_n$. Therefore
$$
lim_ntoinfty b_n=0 iff lim_ntoinfty |a_n|=0.tag1
$$
If the condition $(1)$ is not satisfied $sum a_n$ does not converge as the condition is necessary for convergence of any series.
Therefore if alternating series test fails by this reason, no further tests are needed. The series does not converge.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
If conditions (i) and (ii) are satisfied, then you conclude that the series $bf converges$.
If one of the conditions fails, then you cannot conclude that the series $bf diverges$
The limit $(a_n)$ does not exist because it converges to two different values. In fact, if $n$ is even, then sequence $a_n$ converges to $3/4$ while it converges to $-3/4$ for the odd terms and thus it diverges. In particular, it $lim a_n neq 0$ and so series diverges by divergence test.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Here is a discussion
of a more general case of this.
Suppose
$b_n ge b_n+1$
and
$lim_n to infty b_n
=b > 0
$.
Let
$s_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^nb_n
$.
How does $s_n$ behave?
Let
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^n(b_n-b)
$.
Since
$b_n-b to 0$
and $b_n-b$
is decreasing,
$lim_n to infty t_n$
exists.
Call it $T$.
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$
so
$sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k
=t_n-bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$.
Therefore
$beginarray\
sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n-bsum_k=1^2n (-1)^k\
&=t_2n\
&to T\
textand\
sum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n+1-bsum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^k\
&=t_2n+1+b\
&to T+b\
endarray
$
Note that
$sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
=sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)
to T
$.
Your case is
$b_n
=dfrac3n4n-1
$
so, as you wrote
$b = dfrac34
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfrac34$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac3(2k-1)4(2k-1)-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac6k-38k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac6k(8k-5)-(6k-3)(8k-1)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac48k^2-30k-(48k^2-30k+3)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac-3(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty -dfrac364sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k-1/8)(k-5/8)\
endarray
$
Note that if
$b_n
=dfracunvn+w
$
then
$b = dfracuv
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfracuv$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfracu(2k)v(2k)+w-dfracu(2k-1)v(2k-1)+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac2uk2vk+w-dfrac2uk-u2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac2uk(2vk-v+w)-(2uk-u)(2vk+w)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac4uvk^2+2u(w-v)k-(4uvk^2+2k(uw-uv)-uw)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfracuw(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+(w-v)/(2v))\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+w/(2v)-1/2)\
endarray
$
$endgroup$
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function ()
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix)
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
);
);
, "mathjax-editing");
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "69"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: true,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: 10,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3167910%2falternating-series-test-question%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
Answer to First Question: So, notice that the summand in example 2 has the form
$$(-1)^n b_n = (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
where, clearly, $b_n = frac3n4n-1$. This sequence $b_n = frac3n4n-1$ is the one we must consider in the second condition for the alternating series test.
One condition that we have to check in order to use the alternating series test is that
$$lim b_n = 0$$
However, as the author pointed out,
$$lim b_n = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34 neq 0$$
Therefore, we cannot use the alternating series test to conclude anything; we have to try something else.
Answer to Question 2: To consider the $n$th term of the series means taking an arbitrary term in the series which has the form $(-1)^n frac3n4n-1$. Notice that this includes the $(-1)^n$, as opposed to just the $frac3n4n-1$. We then take
$$lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
Answer to Question 3: It should be clear this sequence $big(-1)^n frac3n4n-1big$ diverges due to oscillation, but we can be a bit more explicit. If the sequence converged, then if we consider the subsequences when $n$ is odd and $n$ is even, they should converge to the same limit.
However, if $n$ is even, then
$$n text even implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34$$
and if $n$ is odd,
$$n text odd implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim - frac3n4n-1 = - frac34$$
Therefore, since these two subsequences do not converge to the same value, it must be that the sequence $big(-1)^nfrac3n4n-1big$ diverges. Hence, by the divergence test, the series in question diverges.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Could you give an example of convergent series with $lim_ntoinfty|a_n|ne0$?
$endgroup$
– user
Mar 31 at 19:57
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Answer to First Question: So, notice that the summand in example 2 has the form
$$(-1)^n b_n = (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
where, clearly, $b_n = frac3n4n-1$. This sequence $b_n = frac3n4n-1$ is the one we must consider in the second condition for the alternating series test.
One condition that we have to check in order to use the alternating series test is that
$$lim b_n = 0$$
However, as the author pointed out,
$$lim b_n = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34 neq 0$$
Therefore, we cannot use the alternating series test to conclude anything; we have to try something else.
Answer to Question 2: To consider the $n$th term of the series means taking an arbitrary term in the series which has the form $(-1)^n frac3n4n-1$. Notice that this includes the $(-1)^n$, as opposed to just the $frac3n4n-1$. We then take
$$lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
Answer to Question 3: It should be clear this sequence $big(-1)^n frac3n4n-1big$ diverges due to oscillation, but we can be a bit more explicit. If the sequence converged, then if we consider the subsequences when $n$ is odd and $n$ is even, they should converge to the same limit.
However, if $n$ is even, then
$$n text even implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34$$
and if $n$ is odd,
$$n text odd implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim - frac3n4n-1 = - frac34$$
Therefore, since these two subsequences do not converge to the same value, it must be that the sequence $big(-1)^nfrac3n4n-1big$ diverges. Hence, by the divergence test, the series in question diverges.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Could you give an example of convergent series with $lim_ntoinfty|a_n|ne0$?
$endgroup$
– user
Mar 31 at 19:57
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Answer to First Question: So, notice that the summand in example 2 has the form
$$(-1)^n b_n = (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
where, clearly, $b_n = frac3n4n-1$. This sequence $b_n = frac3n4n-1$ is the one we must consider in the second condition for the alternating series test.
One condition that we have to check in order to use the alternating series test is that
$$lim b_n = 0$$
However, as the author pointed out,
$$lim b_n = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34 neq 0$$
Therefore, we cannot use the alternating series test to conclude anything; we have to try something else.
Answer to Question 2: To consider the $n$th term of the series means taking an arbitrary term in the series which has the form $(-1)^n frac3n4n-1$. Notice that this includes the $(-1)^n$, as opposed to just the $frac3n4n-1$. We then take
$$lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
Answer to Question 3: It should be clear this sequence $big(-1)^n frac3n4n-1big$ diverges due to oscillation, but we can be a bit more explicit. If the sequence converged, then if we consider the subsequences when $n$ is odd and $n$ is even, they should converge to the same limit.
However, if $n$ is even, then
$$n text even implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34$$
and if $n$ is odd,
$$n text odd implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim - frac3n4n-1 = - frac34$$
Therefore, since these two subsequences do not converge to the same value, it must be that the sequence $big(-1)^nfrac3n4n-1big$ diverges. Hence, by the divergence test, the series in question diverges.
$endgroup$
Answer to First Question: So, notice that the summand in example 2 has the form
$$(-1)^n b_n = (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
where, clearly, $b_n = frac3n4n-1$. This sequence $b_n = frac3n4n-1$ is the one we must consider in the second condition for the alternating series test.
One condition that we have to check in order to use the alternating series test is that
$$lim b_n = 0$$
However, as the author pointed out,
$$lim b_n = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34 neq 0$$
Therefore, we cannot use the alternating series test to conclude anything; we have to try something else.
Answer to Question 2: To consider the $n$th term of the series means taking an arbitrary term in the series which has the form $(-1)^n frac3n4n-1$. Notice that this includes the $(-1)^n$, as opposed to just the $frac3n4n-1$. We then take
$$lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1$$
Answer to Question 3: It should be clear this sequence $big(-1)^n frac3n4n-1big$ diverges due to oscillation, but we can be a bit more explicit. If the sequence converged, then if we consider the subsequences when $n$ is odd and $n$ is even, they should converge to the same limit.
However, if $n$ is even, then
$$n text even implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim frac3n4n-1 = frac34$$
and if $n$ is odd,
$$n text odd implies lim (-1)^n frac3n4n-1 = lim - frac3n4n-1 = - frac34$$
Therefore, since these two subsequences do not converge to the same value, it must be that the sequence $big(-1)^nfrac3n4n-1big$ diverges. Hence, by the divergence test, the series in question diverges.
edited Mar 30 at 15:39
answered Mar 30 at 4:12
Benedict VoltaireBenedict Voltaire
1,347929
1,347929
$begingroup$
Could you give an example of convergent series with $lim_ntoinfty|a_n|ne0$?
$endgroup$
– user
Mar 31 at 19:57
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Could you give an example of convergent series with $lim_ntoinfty|a_n|ne0$?
$endgroup$
– user
Mar 31 at 19:57
$begingroup$
Could you give an example of convergent series with $lim_ntoinfty|a_n|ne0$?
$endgroup$
– user
Mar 31 at 19:57
$begingroup$
Could you give an example of convergent series with $lim_ntoinfty|a_n|ne0$?
$endgroup$
– user
Mar 31 at 19:57
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Your confusion is justified.
From the definition of alternating series $sum_n=1^infty a_n$:
$$
a_n=(-1)^nb_n,quad b_n>0,
$$
it follows that $|a_n|=b_n$. Therefore
$$
lim_ntoinfty b_n=0 iff lim_ntoinfty |a_n|=0.tag1
$$
If the condition $(1)$ is not satisfied $sum a_n$ does not converge as the condition is necessary for convergence of any series.
Therefore if alternating series test fails by this reason, no further tests are needed. The series does not converge.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Your confusion is justified.
From the definition of alternating series $sum_n=1^infty a_n$:
$$
a_n=(-1)^nb_n,quad b_n>0,
$$
it follows that $|a_n|=b_n$. Therefore
$$
lim_ntoinfty b_n=0 iff lim_ntoinfty |a_n|=0.tag1
$$
If the condition $(1)$ is not satisfied $sum a_n$ does not converge as the condition is necessary for convergence of any series.
Therefore if alternating series test fails by this reason, no further tests are needed. The series does not converge.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Your confusion is justified.
From the definition of alternating series $sum_n=1^infty a_n$:
$$
a_n=(-1)^nb_n,quad b_n>0,
$$
it follows that $|a_n|=b_n$. Therefore
$$
lim_ntoinfty b_n=0 iff lim_ntoinfty |a_n|=0.tag1
$$
If the condition $(1)$ is not satisfied $sum a_n$ does not converge as the condition is necessary for convergence of any series.
Therefore if alternating series test fails by this reason, no further tests are needed. The series does not converge.
$endgroup$
Your confusion is justified.
From the definition of alternating series $sum_n=1^infty a_n$:
$$
a_n=(-1)^nb_n,quad b_n>0,
$$
it follows that $|a_n|=b_n$. Therefore
$$
lim_ntoinfty b_n=0 iff lim_ntoinfty |a_n|=0.tag1
$$
If the condition $(1)$ is not satisfied $sum a_n$ does not converge as the condition is necessary for convergence of any series.
Therefore if alternating series test fails by this reason, no further tests are needed. The series does not converge.
edited Apr 1 at 10:52
answered Mar 31 at 23:03
useruser
6,34611031
6,34611031
add a comment |
add a comment |
$begingroup$
If conditions (i) and (ii) are satisfied, then you conclude that the series $bf converges$.
If one of the conditions fails, then you cannot conclude that the series $bf diverges$
The limit $(a_n)$ does not exist because it converges to two different values. In fact, if $n$ is even, then sequence $a_n$ converges to $3/4$ while it converges to $-3/4$ for the odd terms and thus it diverges. In particular, it $lim a_n neq 0$ and so series diverges by divergence test.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
If conditions (i) and (ii) are satisfied, then you conclude that the series $bf converges$.
If one of the conditions fails, then you cannot conclude that the series $bf diverges$
The limit $(a_n)$ does not exist because it converges to two different values. In fact, if $n$ is even, then sequence $a_n$ converges to $3/4$ while it converges to $-3/4$ for the odd terms and thus it diverges. In particular, it $lim a_n neq 0$ and so series diverges by divergence test.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
If conditions (i) and (ii) are satisfied, then you conclude that the series $bf converges$.
If one of the conditions fails, then you cannot conclude that the series $bf diverges$
The limit $(a_n)$ does not exist because it converges to two different values. In fact, if $n$ is even, then sequence $a_n$ converges to $3/4$ while it converges to $-3/4$ for the odd terms and thus it diverges. In particular, it $lim a_n neq 0$ and so series diverges by divergence test.
$endgroup$
If conditions (i) and (ii) are satisfied, then you conclude that the series $bf converges$.
If one of the conditions fails, then you cannot conclude that the series $bf diverges$
The limit $(a_n)$ does not exist because it converges to two different values. In fact, if $n$ is even, then sequence $a_n$ converges to $3/4$ while it converges to $-3/4$ for the odd terms and thus it diverges. In particular, it $lim a_n neq 0$ and so series diverges by divergence test.
answered Mar 30 at 3:59
ILoveMathILoveMath
5,49432373
5,49432373
add a comment |
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Here is a discussion
of a more general case of this.
Suppose
$b_n ge b_n+1$
and
$lim_n to infty b_n
=b > 0
$.
Let
$s_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^nb_n
$.
How does $s_n$ behave?
Let
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^n(b_n-b)
$.
Since
$b_n-b to 0$
and $b_n-b$
is decreasing,
$lim_n to infty t_n$
exists.
Call it $T$.
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$
so
$sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k
=t_n-bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$.
Therefore
$beginarray\
sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n-bsum_k=1^2n (-1)^k\
&=t_2n\
&to T\
textand\
sum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n+1-bsum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^k\
&=t_2n+1+b\
&to T+b\
endarray
$
Note that
$sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
=sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)
to T
$.
Your case is
$b_n
=dfrac3n4n-1
$
so, as you wrote
$b = dfrac34
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfrac34$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac3(2k-1)4(2k-1)-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac6k-38k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac6k(8k-5)-(6k-3)(8k-1)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac48k^2-30k-(48k^2-30k+3)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac-3(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty -dfrac364sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k-1/8)(k-5/8)\
endarray
$
Note that if
$b_n
=dfracunvn+w
$
then
$b = dfracuv
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfracuv$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfracu(2k)v(2k)+w-dfracu(2k-1)v(2k-1)+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac2uk2vk+w-dfrac2uk-u2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac2uk(2vk-v+w)-(2uk-u)(2vk+w)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac4uvk^2+2u(w-v)k-(4uvk^2+2k(uw-uv)-uw)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfracuw(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+(w-v)/(2v))\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+w/(2v)-1/2)\
endarray
$
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Here is a discussion
of a more general case of this.
Suppose
$b_n ge b_n+1$
and
$lim_n to infty b_n
=b > 0
$.
Let
$s_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^nb_n
$.
How does $s_n$ behave?
Let
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^n(b_n-b)
$.
Since
$b_n-b to 0$
and $b_n-b$
is decreasing,
$lim_n to infty t_n$
exists.
Call it $T$.
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$
so
$sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k
=t_n-bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$.
Therefore
$beginarray\
sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n-bsum_k=1^2n (-1)^k\
&=t_2n\
&to T\
textand\
sum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n+1-bsum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^k\
&=t_2n+1+b\
&to T+b\
endarray
$
Note that
$sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
=sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)
to T
$.
Your case is
$b_n
=dfrac3n4n-1
$
so, as you wrote
$b = dfrac34
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfrac34$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac3(2k-1)4(2k-1)-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac6k-38k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac6k(8k-5)-(6k-3)(8k-1)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac48k^2-30k-(48k^2-30k+3)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac-3(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty -dfrac364sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k-1/8)(k-5/8)\
endarray
$
Note that if
$b_n
=dfracunvn+w
$
then
$b = dfracuv
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfracuv$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfracu(2k)v(2k)+w-dfracu(2k-1)v(2k-1)+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac2uk2vk+w-dfrac2uk-u2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac2uk(2vk-v+w)-(2uk-u)(2vk+w)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac4uvk^2+2u(w-v)k-(4uvk^2+2k(uw-uv)-uw)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfracuw(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+(w-v)/(2v))\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+w/(2v)-1/2)\
endarray
$
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Here is a discussion
of a more general case of this.
Suppose
$b_n ge b_n+1$
and
$lim_n to infty b_n
=b > 0
$.
Let
$s_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^nb_n
$.
How does $s_n$ behave?
Let
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^n(b_n-b)
$.
Since
$b_n-b to 0$
and $b_n-b$
is decreasing,
$lim_n to infty t_n$
exists.
Call it $T$.
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$
so
$sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k
=t_n-bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$.
Therefore
$beginarray\
sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n-bsum_k=1^2n (-1)^k\
&=t_2n\
&to T\
textand\
sum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n+1-bsum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^k\
&=t_2n+1+b\
&to T+b\
endarray
$
Note that
$sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
=sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)
to T
$.
Your case is
$b_n
=dfrac3n4n-1
$
so, as you wrote
$b = dfrac34
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfrac34$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac3(2k-1)4(2k-1)-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac6k-38k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac6k(8k-5)-(6k-3)(8k-1)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac48k^2-30k-(48k^2-30k+3)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac-3(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty -dfrac364sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k-1/8)(k-5/8)\
endarray
$
Note that if
$b_n
=dfracunvn+w
$
then
$b = dfracuv
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfracuv$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfracu(2k)v(2k)+w-dfracu(2k-1)v(2k-1)+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac2uk2vk+w-dfrac2uk-u2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac2uk(2vk-v+w)-(2uk-u)(2vk+w)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac4uvk^2+2u(w-v)k-(4uvk^2+2k(uw-uv)-uw)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfracuw(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+(w-v)/(2v))\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+w/(2v)-1/2)\
endarray
$
$endgroup$
Here is a discussion
of a more general case of this.
Suppose
$b_n ge b_n+1$
and
$lim_n to infty b_n
=b > 0
$.
Let
$s_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^nb_n
$.
How does $s_n$ behave?
Let
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^n(b_n-b)
$.
Since
$b_n-b to 0$
and $b_n-b$
is decreasing,
$lim_n to infty t_n$
exists.
Call it $T$.
$t_n
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb
=sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k+bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$
so
$sum_k=1^n (-1)^kb_k
=t_n-bsum_k=1^n (-1)^k
$.
Therefore
$beginarray\
sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n-bsum_k=1^2n (-1)^k\
&=t_2n\
&to T\
textand\
sum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^kb_k
&=t_2n+1-bsum_k=1^2n+1 (-1)^k\
&=t_2n+1+b\
&to T+b\
endarray
$
Note that
$sum_k=1^2n (-1)^kb_k
=sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)
to T
$.
Your case is
$b_n
=dfrac3n4n-1
$
so, as you wrote
$b = dfrac34
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfrac34$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac3(2k-1)4(2k-1)-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac6k8k-1-dfrac6k-38k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac6k(8k-5)-(6k-3)(8k-1)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac48k^2-30k-(48k^2-30k+3)(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac-3(8k-1)(8k-5)\
&=lim_n to infty -dfrac364sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k-1/8)(k-5/8)\
endarray
$
Note that if
$b_n
=dfracunvn+w
$
then
$b = dfracuv
$
so the limit points are
$T$
and
$T+dfracuv$
where
$beginarray\
T
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n (b_2k-b_2k-1)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfracu(2k)v(2k)+w-dfracu(2k-1)v(2k-1)+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^n(dfrac2uk2vk+w-dfrac2uk-u2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac2uk(2vk-v+w)-(2uk-u)(2vk+w)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfrac4uvk^2+2u(w-v)k-(4uvk^2+2k(uw-uv)-uw)(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty sum_k=1^ndfracuw(2vk+w)(2vk-v+w)\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+(w-v)/(2v))\
&=lim_n to infty dfracuw4v^2sum_k=1^ndfrac1(k+w/(2v))(k+w/(2v)-1/2)\
endarray
$
answered Mar 30 at 17:36
marty cohenmarty cohen
75.1k549130
75.1k549130
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3167910%2falternating-series-test-question%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
$begingroup$
ii) fails to hold means that the alternating series test can't conclude if the series converges. You need to find a different test to check convergence.
$endgroup$
– tangentbundle
Mar 30 at 3:57