Does the Symmetric difference operator define a group on the powerset of a set? Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara Planned maintenance scheduled April 17/18, 2019 at 00:00UTC (8:00pm US/Eastern)Proof that the $(mathcal P (mathbb N),triangle)$ is an abelian group?A group that needs to be proven by definition?Finding the type of algebraic structure formed by the given types of setRing structure on power set of a set.abelian finite groups - basicLet $G$ be an abelian group. Define $G^n=lbrace g^n :g in G rbrace$. Show that $G^n$ is a group.a powerset define a group?The group of pure/hereditary setsGroup operation $G,times_21$ with the set set $G=3,6,9,12,15,18$Why don't we need to check for associativity for a subgroup?Does the set operation define a binary operation on G?Find a binary operation on a set of $5$ elements satisfying certain conditions and which does not define a groupDoes this set with this operation define a group?Ring structure on power set of a set.

How did the aliens keep their waters separated?

Why is there no army of Iron-Mans in the MCU?

Can't figure this one out.. What is the missing box?

What kind of display is this?

Geometric mean and geometric standard deviation

How to rotate it perfectly?

Classification of bundles, Postnikov towers, obstruction theory, local coefficients

Was credit for the black hole image misattributed?

What would be Julian Assange's expected punishment, on the current English criminal law?

How to pour concrete for curved walkway to prevent cracking?

3 doors, three guards, one stone

Who can trigger ship-wide alerts in Star Trek?

What to do with post with dry rot?

What was the last x86 CPU that did not have the x87 floating-point unit built in?

Can smartphones with the same camera sensor have different image quality?

Slither Like a Snake

What's the point in a preamp?

Keep going mode for require-package

Am I ethically obligated to go into work on an off day if the reason is sudden?

Single author papers against my advisor's will?

If A makes B more likely then B makes A more likely"

How to add zeros to reach same number of decimal places in tables?

Array/tabular for long multiplication

Should you tell Jews they are breaking a commandment?



Does the Symmetric difference operator define a group on the powerset of a set?



Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara
Planned maintenance scheduled April 17/18, 2019 at 00:00UTC (8:00pm US/Eastern)Proof that the $(mathcal P (mathbb N),triangle)$ is an abelian group?A group that needs to be proven by definition?Finding the type of algebraic structure formed by the given types of setRing structure on power set of a set.abelian finite groups - basicLet $G$ be an abelian group. Define $G^n=lbrace g^n :g in G rbrace$. Show that $G^n$ is a group.a powerset define a group?The group of pure/hereditary setsGroup operation $G,times_21$ with the set set $G=3,6,9,12,15,18$Why don't we need to check for associativity for a subgroup?Does the set operation define a binary operation on G?Find a binary operation on a set of $5$ elements satisfying certain conditions and which does not define a groupDoes this set with this operation define a group?Ring structure on power set of a set.










6












$begingroup$


$G$ is the set of all subsets of a set $A$, under the operation of $triangle;$: Symmetric Difference of sets.



$A$ has at least two different elements.



I need to check if this is a group, and if it does to show if the group is abelian and/or finite.



Associativity - easy from Symmetric Difference.

Identity element - empty group.

Inverse element - each element is inverse to itself.

Am I right?



abelian?

finite?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$











  • $begingroup$
    You are correct.
    $endgroup$
    – Calvin Lin
    Dec 30 '12 at 16:24






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Welcome to MSE. You might consider using more specific, helpful question titles. See this post. For example, for this question your title could be "Is the symmetric difference a group operation?"
    $endgroup$
    – William DeMeo
    Dec 30 '12 at 16:47
















6












$begingroup$


$G$ is the set of all subsets of a set $A$, under the operation of $triangle;$: Symmetric Difference of sets.



$A$ has at least two different elements.



I need to check if this is a group, and if it does to show if the group is abelian and/or finite.



Associativity - easy from Symmetric Difference.

Identity element - empty group.

Inverse element - each element is inverse to itself.

Am I right?



abelian?

finite?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$











  • $begingroup$
    You are correct.
    $endgroup$
    – Calvin Lin
    Dec 30 '12 at 16:24






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Welcome to MSE. You might consider using more specific, helpful question titles. See this post. For example, for this question your title could be "Is the symmetric difference a group operation?"
    $endgroup$
    – William DeMeo
    Dec 30 '12 at 16:47














6












6








6


2



$begingroup$


$G$ is the set of all subsets of a set $A$, under the operation of $triangle;$: Symmetric Difference of sets.



$A$ has at least two different elements.



I need to check if this is a group, and if it does to show if the group is abelian and/or finite.



Associativity - easy from Symmetric Difference.

Identity element - empty group.

Inverse element - each element is inverse to itself.

Am I right?



abelian?

finite?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$




$G$ is the set of all subsets of a set $A$, under the operation of $triangle;$: Symmetric Difference of sets.



$A$ has at least two different elements.



I need to check if this is a group, and if it does to show if the group is abelian and/or finite.



Associativity - easy from Symmetric Difference.

Identity element - empty group.

Inverse element - each element is inverse to itself.

Am I right?



abelian?

finite?







abstract-algebra group-theory






share|cite|improve this question















share|cite|improve this question













share|cite|improve this question




share|cite|improve this question








edited Dec 22 '13 at 14:08









Namaste

1




1










asked Dec 30 '12 at 16:21









AnnaAnna

8119




8119











  • $begingroup$
    You are correct.
    $endgroup$
    – Calvin Lin
    Dec 30 '12 at 16:24






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Welcome to MSE. You might consider using more specific, helpful question titles. See this post. For example, for this question your title could be "Is the symmetric difference a group operation?"
    $endgroup$
    – William DeMeo
    Dec 30 '12 at 16:47

















  • $begingroup$
    You are correct.
    $endgroup$
    – Calvin Lin
    Dec 30 '12 at 16:24






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Welcome to MSE. You might consider using more specific, helpful question titles. See this post. For example, for this question your title could be "Is the symmetric difference a group operation?"
    $endgroup$
    – William DeMeo
    Dec 30 '12 at 16:47
















$begingroup$
You are correct.
$endgroup$
– Calvin Lin
Dec 30 '12 at 16:24




$begingroup$
You are correct.
$endgroup$
– Calvin Lin
Dec 30 '12 at 16:24




1




1




$begingroup$
Welcome to MSE. You might consider using more specific, helpful question titles. See this post. For example, for this question your title could be "Is the symmetric difference a group operation?"
$endgroup$
– William DeMeo
Dec 30 '12 at 16:47





$begingroup$
Welcome to MSE. You might consider using more specific, helpful question titles. See this post. For example, for this question your title could be "Is the symmetric difference a group operation?"
$endgroup$
– William DeMeo
Dec 30 '12 at 16:47











3 Answers
3






active

oldest

votes


















6












$begingroup$

First to get clear about the set $G$: it is the set of all subsets of a set $A$. (So the elements of $G$ are sets.) And by definition, $G$ is therefore the powerset of $A$, denoted $G =mathcalP(A))$. So $|G| = 2^$, which is finite if and only if $|A|$ is finite, and is infinite otherwise.



The operation on the sets $g_1, g_2 in G$ is the symmetric difference of $;g_1;$ and $;g_2;$ which we'll denote as $;g_1;triangle;g_2;$ and is defined as the set of elements which are in either of the sets but not in their intersection: $;g_1;triangle;g_2 ;= ;(g_1cup g_2) - (g_1 cap g_2)tag1$



Hence, the symmetric difference $g_i ;triangle; g_j in G;$ for all $;g_i, g_j in G$. ($G$ is the set of ALL subsets of $A$, so it must include any possible set resulting from symmetric difference between any arbitrary sets in $G$, which are also subsets of $A$). That is we have now established, that the symmetric difference is closed on $G$.



The power set $G$ of any set $A$ becomes an abelian group under the operation of symmetric difference:



  • Why abelian? Easy to justify, just use the definition in $(1)$ above: it's defined in a way that $g_1 triangle g_2$ means exactly the same set as $g_2 triangle g_1$, for any two $g in G$.


  • As you note, the symmetric difference on $G$ is associative, which can be shown using the definition in $(1)$, by showing for any $f, g, h in G, (f; triangle; g) triangle ;h = f;triangle; (g ;triangle; h)$.


  • The empty set is the identity of the group (it would be good to justify this this, too), and


  • every element in this group is its own inverse. (Can you justify this, as well? Just show for any $g_i in G, g_i;triangle ; g_i = varnothing$).


The justifications for these properties is very straightforward, but good to include for a proof that the symmetric difference, together with the set $G$ as defined, form an abelian group.




So, you've covered most of the bases, but you simply want to confirm/note the closure of the symmetric difference operation on $G$ and why, add a bit of justification for the identity and inverse claims, and to address whether, or when, $G$ is finite/infinite: this last point being that the order of $G$ depends on the cardinality of $A$.






share|cite|improve this answer











$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    wow thank you so much!!!
    $endgroup$
    – Anna
    Dec 30 '12 at 19:34











  • $begingroup$
    You're welcome, Anna!
    $endgroup$
    – Namaste
    Dec 30 '12 at 19:48










  • $begingroup$
    If instead of the set of all subsets, we take a class of such subsets how can we guarantee the closure? In other words, my question is: given a class $C$ of subsets of a set $X$, is $(C,triangle)$ an abelian group?
    $endgroup$
    – андрэ
    Sep 23 '17 at 15:38


















4












$begingroup$

This is intended to be a comment to amWhy's answer. However, my comment is too long to fit in the comment box, plus I suspect my comment might be of sufficient interest to some people here to warrant a more public display.



Carolyn Bean (reference below) proved a number of interesting group-theoretic results related to the symmetric difference operation, a few of which I will state here. Let $X$ be a fixed set and let $cal P(X)$ be the set of all subsets of $X.$ Bean proved that $Delta$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A*B subseteq A cup B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Define the co-symmetric difference operation $nabla$ on $cal P(X)$ by $A nabla B = X - (A Delta B)$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Then one can show that $left(,cal P(X),;nablaright)$ is also an abelian group. Bean proved that $nabla$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A cap B subseteq A*B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Bean additionally proved that $left(,cal P(X),;Delta,;capright)$ and $left(,cal P(X),;nabla,;cupright)$ are isomorphic commutative rings with identity.



Carolyn Bean, Group operations on the power set, Journal of Undergraduate Mathematics 8 #1 (March 1976), 13-17.






share|cite|improve this answer









$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    Hi Dave, that sounds interesting, is the article available in www?
    $endgroup$
    – Sven Wirsing
    Sep 21 '14 at 7:55










  • $begingroup$
    @Sven Wirsing: I have not previously found it on the internet, and I looked just now and didn't find it. The is not very well known, but it's available in many U.S. libraries. FYI, I first learned about the journal in the late 1970s, well before the internet. While I'm here, you might be interested in my manuscript Exotic Group Examples that I posted (don't remember when) at Math Forum.
    $endgroup$
    – Dave L. Renfro
    Sep 22 '14 at 15:50



















1












$begingroup$

You should also mention that $g_1,g_2in G$ then so is $g_1*g_2$ but other than that it looks OK to me.



Regarding being finite - you should know that if $A$ is finite and have $n$ elements then there are $2^n$ subsets of $A$ (or give any other argument to show that your group is finite).



If $A$ is infinite then there are infinite singeltons hence your group is also infinite.






share|cite|improve this answer









$endgroup$













    Your Answer








    StackExchange.ready(function()
    var channelOptions =
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "69"
    ;
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
    createEditor();
    );

    else
    createEditor();

    );

    function createEditor()
    StackExchange.prepareEditor(
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
    convertImagesToLinks: true,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: 10,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader:
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    ,
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    );



    );













    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function ()
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f267708%2fdoes-the-symmetric-difference-operator-define-a-group-on-the-powerset-of-a-set%23new-answer', 'question_page');

    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    3 Answers
    3






    active

    oldest

    votes








    3 Answers
    3






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    6












    $begingroup$

    First to get clear about the set $G$: it is the set of all subsets of a set $A$. (So the elements of $G$ are sets.) And by definition, $G$ is therefore the powerset of $A$, denoted $G =mathcalP(A))$. So $|G| = 2^$, which is finite if and only if $|A|$ is finite, and is infinite otherwise.



    The operation on the sets $g_1, g_2 in G$ is the symmetric difference of $;g_1;$ and $;g_2;$ which we'll denote as $;g_1;triangle;g_2;$ and is defined as the set of elements which are in either of the sets but not in their intersection: $;g_1;triangle;g_2 ;= ;(g_1cup g_2) - (g_1 cap g_2)tag1$



    Hence, the symmetric difference $g_i ;triangle; g_j in G;$ for all $;g_i, g_j in G$. ($G$ is the set of ALL subsets of $A$, so it must include any possible set resulting from symmetric difference between any arbitrary sets in $G$, which are also subsets of $A$). That is we have now established, that the symmetric difference is closed on $G$.



    The power set $G$ of any set $A$ becomes an abelian group under the operation of symmetric difference:



    • Why abelian? Easy to justify, just use the definition in $(1)$ above: it's defined in a way that $g_1 triangle g_2$ means exactly the same set as $g_2 triangle g_1$, for any two $g in G$.


    • As you note, the symmetric difference on $G$ is associative, which can be shown using the definition in $(1)$, by showing for any $f, g, h in G, (f; triangle; g) triangle ;h = f;triangle; (g ;triangle; h)$.


    • The empty set is the identity of the group (it would be good to justify this this, too), and


    • every element in this group is its own inverse. (Can you justify this, as well? Just show for any $g_i in G, g_i;triangle ; g_i = varnothing$).


    The justifications for these properties is very straightforward, but good to include for a proof that the symmetric difference, together with the set $G$ as defined, form an abelian group.




    So, you've covered most of the bases, but you simply want to confirm/note the closure of the symmetric difference operation on $G$ and why, add a bit of justification for the identity and inverse claims, and to address whether, or when, $G$ is finite/infinite: this last point being that the order of $G$ depends on the cardinality of $A$.






    share|cite|improve this answer











    $endgroup$












    • $begingroup$
      wow thank you so much!!!
      $endgroup$
      – Anna
      Dec 30 '12 at 19:34











    • $begingroup$
      You're welcome, Anna!
      $endgroup$
      – Namaste
      Dec 30 '12 at 19:48










    • $begingroup$
      If instead of the set of all subsets, we take a class of such subsets how can we guarantee the closure? In other words, my question is: given a class $C$ of subsets of a set $X$, is $(C,triangle)$ an abelian group?
      $endgroup$
      – андрэ
      Sep 23 '17 at 15:38















    6












    $begingroup$

    First to get clear about the set $G$: it is the set of all subsets of a set $A$. (So the elements of $G$ are sets.) And by definition, $G$ is therefore the powerset of $A$, denoted $G =mathcalP(A))$. So $|G| = 2^$, which is finite if and only if $|A|$ is finite, and is infinite otherwise.



    The operation on the sets $g_1, g_2 in G$ is the symmetric difference of $;g_1;$ and $;g_2;$ which we'll denote as $;g_1;triangle;g_2;$ and is defined as the set of elements which are in either of the sets but not in their intersection: $;g_1;triangle;g_2 ;= ;(g_1cup g_2) - (g_1 cap g_2)tag1$



    Hence, the symmetric difference $g_i ;triangle; g_j in G;$ for all $;g_i, g_j in G$. ($G$ is the set of ALL subsets of $A$, so it must include any possible set resulting from symmetric difference between any arbitrary sets in $G$, which are also subsets of $A$). That is we have now established, that the symmetric difference is closed on $G$.



    The power set $G$ of any set $A$ becomes an abelian group under the operation of symmetric difference:



    • Why abelian? Easy to justify, just use the definition in $(1)$ above: it's defined in a way that $g_1 triangle g_2$ means exactly the same set as $g_2 triangle g_1$, for any two $g in G$.


    • As you note, the symmetric difference on $G$ is associative, which can be shown using the definition in $(1)$, by showing for any $f, g, h in G, (f; triangle; g) triangle ;h = f;triangle; (g ;triangle; h)$.


    • The empty set is the identity of the group (it would be good to justify this this, too), and


    • every element in this group is its own inverse. (Can you justify this, as well? Just show for any $g_i in G, g_i;triangle ; g_i = varnothing$).


    The justifications for these properties is very straightforward, but good to include for a proof that the symmetric difference, together with the set $G$ as defined, form an abelian group.




    So, you've covered most of the bases, but you simply want to confirm/note the closure of the symmetric difference operation on $G$ and why, add a bit of justification for the identity and inverse claims, and to address whether, or when, $G$ is finite/infinite: this last point being that the order of $G$ depends on the cardinality of $A$.






    share|cite|improve this answer











    $endgroup$












    • $begingroup$
      wow thank you so much!!!
      $endgroup$
      – Anna
      Dec 30 '12 at 19:34











    • $begingroup$
      You're welcome, Anna!
      $endgroup$
      – Namaste
      Dec 30 '12 at 19:48










    • $begingroup$
      If instead of the set of all subsets, we take a class of such subsets how can we guarantee the closure? In other words, my question is: given a class $C$ of subsets of a set $X$, is $(C,triangle)$ an abelian group?
      $endgroup$
      – андрэ
      Sep 23 '17 at 15:38













    6












    6








    6





    $begingroup$

    First to get clear about the set $G$: it is the set of all subsets of a set $A$. (So the elements of $G$ are sets.) And by definition, $G$ is therefore the powerset of $A$, denoted $G =mathcalP(A))$. So $|G| = 2^$, which is finite if and only if $|A|$ is finite, and is infinite otherwise.



    The operation on the sets $g_1, g_2 in G$ is the symmetric difference of $;g_1;$ and $;g_2;$ which we'll denote as $;g_1;triangle;g_2;$ and is defined as the set of elements which are in either of the sets but not in their intersection: $;g_1;triangle;g_2 ;= ;(g_1cup g_2) - (g_1 cap g_2)tag1$



    Hence, the symmetric difference $g_i ;triangle; g_j in G;$ for all $;g_i, g_j in G$. ($G$ is the set of ALL subsets of $A$, so it must include any possible set resulting from symmetric difference between any arbitrary sets in $G$, which are also subsets of $A$). That is we have now established, that the symmetric difference is closed on $G$.



    The power set $G$ of any set $A$ becomes an abelian group under the operation of symmetric difference:



    • Why abelian? Easy to justify, just use the definition in $(1)$ above: it's defined in a way that $g_1 triangle g_2$ means exactly the same set as $g_2 triangle g_1$, for any two $g in G$.


    • As you note, the symmetric difference on $G$ is associative, which can be shown using the definition in $(1)$, by showing for any $f, g, h in G, (f; triangle; g) triangle ;h = f;triangle; (g ;triangle; h)$.


    • The empty set is the identity of the group (it would be good to justify this this, too), and


    • every element in this group is its own inverse. (Can you justify this, as well? Just show for any $g_i in G, g_i;triangle ; g_i = varnothing$).


    The justifications for these properties is very straightforward, but good to include for a proof that the symmetric difference, together with the set $G$ as defined, form an abelian group.




    So, you've covered most of the bases, but you simply want to confirm/note the closure of the symmetric difference operation on $G$ and why, add a bit of justification for the identity and inverse claims, and to address whether, or when, $G$ is finite/infinite: this last point being that the order of $G$ depends on the cardinality of $A$.






    share|cite|improve this answer











    $endgroup$



    First to get clear about the set $G$: it is the set of all subsets of a set $A$. (So the elements of $G$ are sets.) And by definition, $G$ is therefore the powerset of $A$, denoted $G =mathcalP(A))$. So $|G| = 2^$, which is finite if and only if $|A|$ is finite, and is infinite otherwise.



    The operation on the sets $g_1, g_2 in G$ is the symmetric difference of $;g_1;$ and $;g_2;$ which we'll denote as $;g_1;triangle;g_2;$ and is defined as the set of elements which are in either of the sets but not in their intersection: $;g_1;triangle;g_2 ;= ;(g_1cup g_2) - (g_1 cap g_2)tag1$



    Hence, the symmetric difference $g_i ;triangle; g_j in G;$ for all $;g_i, g_j in G$. ($G$ is the set of ALL subsets of $A$, so it must include any possible set resulting from symmetric difference between any arbitrary sets in $G$, which are also subsets of $A$). That is we have now established, that the symmetric difference is closed on $G$.



    The power set $G$ of any set $A$ becomes an abelian group under the operation of symmetric difference:



    • Why abelian? Easy to justify, just use the definition in $(1)$ above: it's defined in a way that $g_1 triangle g_2$ means exactly the same set as $g_2 triangle g_1$, for any two $g in G$.


    • As you note, the symmetric difference on $G$ is associative, which can be shown using the definition in $(1)$, by showing for any $f, g, h in G, (f; triangle; g) triangle ;h = f;triangle; (g ;triangle; h)$.


    • The empty set is the identity of the group (it would be good to justify this this, too), and


    • every element in this group is its own inverse. (Can you justify this, as well? Just show for any $g_i in G, g_i;triangle ; g_i = varnothing$).


    The justifications for these properties is very straightforward, but good to include for a proof that the symmetric difference, together with the set $G$ as defined, form an abelian group.




    So, you've covered most of the bases, but you simply want to confirm/note the closure of the symmetric difference operation on $G$ and why, add a bit of justification for the identity and inverse claims, and to address whether, or when, $G$ is finite/infinite: this last point being that the order of $G$ depends on the cardinality of $A$.







    share|cite|improve this answer














    share|cite|improve this answer



    share|cite|improve this answer








    edited Dec 30 '12 at 20:40

























    answered Dec 30 '12 at 18:43









    NamasteNamaste

    1




    1











    • $begingroup$
      wow thank you so much!!!
      $endgroup$
      – Anna
      Dec 30 '12 at 19:34











    • $begingroup$
      You're welcome, Anna!
      $endgroup$
      – Namaste
      Dec 30 '12 at 19:48










    • $begingroup$
      If instead of the set of all subsets, we take a class of such subsets how can we guarantee the closure? In other words, my question is: given a class $C$ of subsets of a set $X$, is $(C,triangle)$ an abelian group?
      $endgroup$
      – андрэ
      Sep 23 '17 at 15:38
















    • $begingroup$
      wow thank you so much!!!
      $endgroup$
      – Anna
      Dec 30 '12 at 19:34











    • $begingroup$
      You're welcome, Anna!
      $endgroup$
      – Namaste
      Dec 30 '12 at 19:48










    • $begingroup$
      If instead of the set of all subsets, we take a class of such subsets how can we guarantee the closure? In other words, my question is: given a class $C$ of subsets of a set $X$, is $(C,triangle)$ an abelian group?
      $endgroup$
      – андрэ
      Sep 23 '17 at 15:38















    $begingroup$
    wow thank you so much!!!
    $endgroup$
    – Anna
    Dec 30 '12 at 19:34





    $begingroup$
    wow thank you so much!!!
    $endgroup$
    – Anna
    Dec 30 '12 at 19:34













    $begingroup$
    You're welcome, Anna!
    $endgroup$
    – Namaste
    Dec 30 '12 at 19:48




    $begingroup$
    You're welcome, Anna!
    $endgroup$
    – Namaste
    Dec 30 '12 at 19:48












    $begingroup$
    If instead of the set of all subsets, we take a class of such subsets how can we guarantee the closure? In other words, my question is: given a class $C$ of subsets of a set $X$, is $(C,triangle)$ an abelian group?
    $endgroup$
    – андрэ
    Sep 23 '17 at 15:38




    $begingroup$
    If instead of the set of all subsets, we take a class of such subsets how can we guarantee the closure? In other words, my question is: given a class $C$ of subsets of a set $X$, is $(C,triangle)$ an abelian group?
    $endgroup$
    – андрэ
    Sep 23 '17 at 15:38











    4












    $begingroup$

    This is intended to be a comment to amWhy's answer. However, my comment is too long to fit in the comment box, plus I suspect my comment might be of sufficient interest to some people here to warrant a more public display.



    Carolyn Bean (reference below) proved a number of interesting group-theoretic results related to the symmetric difference operation, a few of which I will state here. Let $X$ be a fixed set and let $cal P(X)$ be the set of all subsets of $X.$ Bean proved that $Delta$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A*B subseteq A cup B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Define the co-symmetric difference operation $nabla$ on $cal P(X)$ by $A nabla B = X - (A Delta B)$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Then one can show that $left(,cal P(X),;nablaright)$ is also an abelian group. Bean proved that $nabla$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A cap B subseteq A*B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Bean additionally proved that $left(,cal P(X),;Delta,;capright)$ and $left(,cal P(X),;nabla,;cupright)$ are isomorphic commutative rings with identity.



    Carolyn Bean, Group operations on the power set, Journal of Undergraduate Mathematics 8 #1 (March 1976), 13-17.






    share|cite|improve this answer









    $endgroup$












    • $begingroup$
      Hi Dave, that sounds interesting, is the article available in www?
      $endgroup$
      – Sven Wirsing
      Sep 21 '14 at 7:55










    • $begingroup$
      @Sven Wirsing: I have not previously found it on the internet, and I looked just now and didn't find it. The is not very well known, but it's available in many U.S. libraries. FYI, I first learned about the journal in the late 1970s, well before the internet. While I'm here, you might be interested in my manuscript Exotic Group Examples that I posted (don't remember when) at Math Forum.
      $endgroup$
      – Dave L. Renfro
      Sep 22 '14 at 15:50
















    4












    $begingroup$

    This is intended to be a comment to amWhy's answer. However, my comment is too long to fit in the comment box, plus I suspect my comment might be of sufficient interest to some people here to warrant a more public display.



    Carolyn Bean (reference below) proved a number of interesting group-theoretic results related to the symmetric difference operation, a few of which I will state here. Let $X$ be a fixed set and let $cal P(X)$ be the set of all subsets of $X.$ Bean proved that $Delta$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A*B subseteq A cup B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Define the co-symmetric difference operation $nabla$ on $cal P(X)$ by $A nabla B = X - (A Delta B)$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Then one can show that $left(,cal P(X),;nablaright)$ is also an abelian group. Bean proved that $nabla$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A cap B subseteq A*B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Bean additionally proved that $left(,cal P(X),;Delta,;capright)$ and $left(,cal P(X),;nabla,;cupright)$ are isomorphic commutative rings with identity.



    Carolyn Bean, Group operations on the power set, Journal of Undergraduate Mathematics 8 #1 (March 1976), 13-17.






    share|cite|improve this answer









    $endgroup$












    • $begingroup$
      Hi Dave, that sounds interesting, is the article available in www?
      $endgroup$
      – Sven Wirsing
      Sep 21 '14 at 7:55










    • $begingroup$
      @Sven Wirsing: I have not previously found it on the internet, and I looked just now and didn't find it. The is not very well known, but it's available in many U.S. libraries. FYI, I first learned about the journal in the late 1970s, well before the internet. While I'm here, you might be interested in my manuscript Exotic Group Examples that I posted (don't remember when) at Math Forum.
      $endgroup$
      – Dave L. Renfro
      Sep 22 '14 at 15:50














    4












    4








    4





    $begingroup$

    This is intended to be a comment to amWhy's answer. However, my comment is too long to fit in the comment box, plus I suspect my comment might be of sufficient interest to some people here to warrant a more public display.



    Carolyn Bean (reference below) proved a number of interesting group-theoretic results related to the symmetric difference operation, a few of which I will state here. Let $X$ be a fixed set and let $cal P(X)$ be the set of all subsets of $X.$ Bean proved that $Delta$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A*B subseteq A cup B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Define the co-symmetric difference operation $nabla$ on $cal P(X)$ by $A nabla B = X - (A Delta B)$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Then one can show that $left(,cal P(X),;nablaright)$ is also an abelian group. Bean proved that $nabla$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A cap B subseteq A*B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Bean additionally proved that $left(,cal P(X),;Delta,;capright)$ and $left(,cal P(X),;nabla,;cupright)$ are isomorphic commutative rings with identity.



    Carolyn Bean, Group operations on the power set, Journal of Undergraduate Mathematics 8 #1 (March 1976), 13-17.






    share|cite|improve this answer









    $endgroup$



    This is intended to be a comment to amWhy's answer. However, my comment is too long to fit in the comment box, plus I suspect my comment might be of sufficient interest to some people here to warrant a more public display.



    Carolyn Bean (reference below) proved a number of interesting group-theoretic results related to the symmetric difference operation, a few of which I will state here. Let $X$ be a fixed set and let $cal P(X)$ be the set of all subsets of $X.$ Bean proved that $Delta$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A*B subseteq A cup B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Define the co-symmetric difference operation $nabla$ on $cal P(X)$ by $A nabla B = X - (A Delta B)$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Then one can show that $left(,cal P(X),;nablaright)$ is also an abelian group. Bean proved that $nabla$ can be characterized as the unique group operation $*$ on $cal P(X)$ such that $A cap B subseteq A*B$ for all $A,$ $B in cal P(X).$ Bean additionally proved that $left(,cal P(X),;Delta,;capright)$ and $left(,cal P(X),;nabla,;cupright)$ are isomorphic commutative rings with identity.



    Carolyn Bean, Group operations on the power set, Journal of Undergraduate Mathematics 8 #1 (March 1976), 13-17.







    share|cite|improve this answer












    share|cite|improve this answer



    share|cite|improve this answer










    answered Jan 2 '13 at 20:48









    Dave L. RenfroDave L. Renfro

    25.4k34082




    25.4k34082











    • $begingroup$
      Hi Dave, that sounds interesting, is the article available in www?
      $endgroup$
      – Sven Wirsing
      Sep 21 '14 at 7:55










    • $begingroup$
      @Sven Wirsing: I have not previously found it on the internet, and I looked just now and didn't find it. The is not very well known, but it's available in many U.S. libraries. FYI, I first learned about the journal in the late 1970s, well before the internet. While I'm here, you might be interested in my manuscript Exotic Group Examples that I posted (don't remember when) at Math Forum.
      $endgroup$
      – Dave L. Renfro
      Sep 22 '14 at 15:50

















    • $begingroup$
      Hi Dave, that sounds interesting, is the article available in www?
      $endgroup$
      – Sven Wirsing
      Sep 21 '14 at 7:55










    • $begingroup$
      @Sven Wirsing: I have not previously found it on the internet, and I looked just now and didn't find it. The is not very well known, but it's available in many U.S. libraries. FYI, I first learned about the journal in the late 1970s, well before the internet. While I'm here, you might be interested in my manuscript Exotic Group Examples that I posted (don't remember when) at Math Forum.
      $endgroup$
      – Dave L. Renfro
      Sep 22 '14 at 15:50
















    $begingroup$
    Hi Dave, that sounds interesting, is the article available in www?
    $endgroup$
    – Sven Wirsing
    Sep 21 '14 at 7:55




    $begingroup$
    Hi Dave, that sounds interesting, is the article available in www?
    $endgroup$
    – Sven Wirsing
    Sep 21 '14 at 7:55












    $begingroup$
    @Sven Wirsing: I have not previously found it on the internet, and I looked just now and didn't find it. The is not very well known, but it's available in many U.S. libraries. FYI, I first learned about the journal in the late 1970s, well before the internet. While I'm here, you might be interested in my manuscript Exotic Group Examples that I posted (don't remember when) at Math Forum.
    $endgroup$
    – Dave L. Renfro
    Sep 22 '14 at 15:50





    $begingroup$
    @Sven Wirsing: I have not previously found it on the internet, and I looked just now and didn't find it. The is not very well known, but it's available in many U.S. libraries. FYI, I first learned about the journal in the late 1970s, well before the internet. While I'm here, you might be interested in my manuscript Exotic Group Examples that I posted (don't remember when) at Math Forum.
    $endgroup$
    – Dave L. Renfro
    Sep 22 '14 at 15:50












    1












    $begingroup$

    You should also mention that $g_1,g_2in G$ then so is $g_1*g_2$ but other than that it looks OK to me.



    Regarding being finite - you should know that if $A$ is finite and have $n$ elements then there are $2^n$ subsets of $A$ (or give any other argument to show that your group is finite).



    If $A$ is infinite then there are infinite singeltons hence your group is also infinite.






    share|cite|improve this answer









    $endgroup$

















      1












      $begingroup$

      You should also mention that $g_1,g_2in G$ then so is $g_1*g_2$ but other than that it looks OK to me.



      Regarding being finite - you should know that if $A$ is finite and have $n$ elements then there are $2^n$ subsets of $A$ (or give any other argument to show that your group is finite).



      If $A$ is infinite then there are infinite singeltons hence your group is also infinite.






      share|cite|improve this answer









      $endgroup$















        1












        1








        1





        $begingroup$

        You should also mention that $g_1,g_2in G$ then so is $g_1*g_2$ but other than that it looks OK to me.



        Regarding being finite - you should know that if $A$ is finite and have $n$ elements then there are $2^n$ subsets of $A$ (or give any other argument to show that your group is finite).



        If $A$ is infinite then there are infinite singeltons hence your group is also infinite.






        share|cite|improve this answer









        $endgroup$



        You should also mention that $g_1,g_2in G$ then so is $g_1*g_2$ but other than that it looks OK to me.



        Regarding being finite - you should know that if $A$ is finite and have $n$ elements then there are $2^n$ subsets of $A$ (or give any other argument to show that your group is finite).



        If $A$ is infinite then there are infinite singeltons hence your group is also infinite.







        share|cite|improve this answer












        share|cite|improve this answer



        share|cite|improve this answer










        answered Dec 30 '12 at 16:26









        BelgiBelgi

        14.7k1155115




        14.7k1155115



























            draft saved

            draft discarded
















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid


            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

            Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function ()
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f267708%2fdoes-the-symmetric-difference-operator-define-a-group-on-the-powerset-of-a-set%23new-answer', 'question_page');

            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            Boston (Lincolnshire) Stedsbyld | Berne yn Boston | NavigaasjemenuBoston Borough CouncilBoston, Lincolnshire

            Ballerup Komuun Stääden an saarpen | Futnuuten | Luke uk diar | Nawigatsjuunwww.ballerup.dkwww.statistikbanken.dk: Tabelle BEF44 (Folketal pr. 1. januar fordelt på byer)Commonskategorii: Ballerup Komuun55° 44′ N, 12° 22′ O

            Serbia Índice Etimología Historia Geografía Entorno natural División administrativa Política Demografía Economía Cultura Deportes Véase también Notas Referencias Bibliografía Enlaces externos Menú de navegación44°49′00″N 20°28′00″E / 44.816666666667, 20.46666666666744°49′00″N 20°28′00″E / 44.816666666667, 20.466666666667U.S. Department of Commerce (2015)«Informe sobre Desarrollo Humano 2018»Kosovo-Metohija.Neutralna Srbija u NATO okruzenju.The SerbsTheories on the Origin of the Serbs.Serbia.Earls: Webster's Quotations, Facts and Phrases.Egeo y Balcanes.Kalemegdan.Southern Pannonia during the age of the Great Migrations.Culture in Serbia.History.The Serbian Origin of the Montenegrins.Nemanjics' period (1186-1353).Stefan Uros (1355-1371).Serbian medieval history.Habsburg–Ottoman Wars (1525–1718).The Ottoman Empire, 1700-1922.The First Serbian Uprising.Miloš, prince of Serbia.3. Bosnia-Hercegovina and the Congress of Berlin.The Balkan Wars and the Partition of Macedonia.The Falcon and the Eagle: Montenegro and Austria-Hungary, 1908-1914.Typhus fever on the eastern front in World War I.Anniversary of WWI battle marked in Serbia.La derrota austriaca en los Balcanes. Fin del Imperio Austro-Húngaro.Imperio austriaco y Reino de Hungría.Los tiempos modernos: del capitalismo a la globalización, siglos XVII al XXI.The period of Croatia within ex-Yugoslavia.Yugoslavia: Much in a Name.Las dictaduras europeas.Croacia: mito y realidad."Crods ask arms".Prólogo a la invasión.La campaña de los Balcanes.La resistencia en Yugoslavia.Jasenovac Research Institute.Día en memoria de las víctimas del genocidio en la Segunda Guerra Mundial.El infierno estuvo en Jasenovac.Croacia empieza a «desenterrar» a sus muertos de Jasenovac.World fascism: a historical encyclopedia, Volumen 1.Tito. Josip Broz.El nuevo orden y la resistencia.La conquista del poder.Algunos aspectos de la economía yugoslava a mediados de 1962.Albania-Kosovo crisis.De Kosovo a Kosova: una visión demográfica.La crisis de la economía yugoslava y la política de "estabilización".Milosevic: el poder de un absolutista."Serbia under Milošević: politics in the 1990s"Milosevic cavó en Kosovo la tumba de la antigua Yugoslavia.La ONU exculpa a Serbia de genocidio en la guerra de Bosnia.Slobodan Milosevic, el burócrata que supo usar el odio.Es la fuerza contra el sufrimiento de muchos inocentes.Matanza de civiles al bombardear la OTAN un puente mientras pasaba un tren.Las consecuencias negativas de los bombardeos de Yugoslavia se sentirán aún durante largo tiempo.Kostunica advierte que la misión de Europa en Kosovo es ilegal.Las 24 horas más largas en la vida de Slobodan Milosevic.Serbia declara la guerra a la mafia por matar a Djindjic.Tadic presentará "quizás en diciembre" la solicitud de entrada en la UE.Montenegro declara su independencia de Serbia.Serbia se declara estado soberano tras separación de Montenegro.«Accordance with International Law of the Unilateral Declaration of Independence by the Provisional Institutions of Self-Government of Kosovo (Request for Advisory Opinion)»Mladic pasa por el médico antes de la audiencia para extraditarloDatos de Serbia y Kosovo.The Carpathian Mountains.Position, Relief, Climate.Transport.Finding birds in Serbia.U Srbiji do 2010. godine 10% teritorije nacionalni parkovi.Geography.Serbia: Climate.Variability of Climate In Serbia In The Second Half of The 20thc Entury.BASIC CLIMATE CHARACTERISTICS FOR THE TERRITORY OF SERBIA.Fauna y flora: Serbia.Serbia and Montenegro.Información general sobre Serbia.Republic of Serbia Environmental Protection Agency (SEPA).Serbia recycling 15% of waste.Reform process of the Serbian energy sector.20-MW Wind Project Being Developed in Serbia.Las Naciones Unidas. Paz para Kosovo.Aniversario sin fiesta.Population by national or ethnic groups by Census 2002.Article 7. Coat of arms, flag and national anthem.Serbia, flag of.Historia.«Serbia and Montenegro in Pictures»Serbia.Serbia aprueba su nueva Constitución con un apoyo de más del 50%.Serbia. Population.«El nacionalista Nikolic gana las elecciones presidenciales en Serbia»El europeísta Borís Tadic gana la segunda vuelta de las presidenciales serbias.Aleksandar Vucic, de ultranacionalista serbio a fervoroso europeístaKostunica condena la declaración del "falso estado" de Kosovo.Comienza el debate sobre la independencia de Kosovo en el TIJ.La Corte Internacional de Justicia dice que Kosovo no violó el derecho internacional al declarar su independenciaKosovo: Enviado de la ONU advierte tensiones y fragilidad.«Bruselas recomienda negociar la adhesión de Serbia tras el acuerdo sobre Kosovo»Monografía de Serbia.Bez smanjivanja Vojske Srbije.Military statistics Serbia and Montenegro.Šutanovac: Vojni budžet za 2009. godinu 70 milijardi dinara.Serbia-Montenegro shortens obligatory military service to six months.No hay justicia para las víctimas de los bombardeos de la OTAN.Zapatero reitera la negativa de España a reconocer la independencia de Kosovo.Anniversary of the signing of the Stabilisation and Association Agreement.Detenido en Serbia Radovan Karadzic, el criminal de guerra más buscado de Europa."Serbia presentará su candidatura de acceso a la UE antes de fin de año".Serbia solicita la adhesión a la UE.Detenido el exgeneral serbobosnio Ratko Mladic, principal acusado del genocidio en los Balcanes«Lista de todos los Estados Miembros de las Naciones Unidas que son parte o signatarios en los diversos instrumentos de derechos humanos de las Naciones Unidas»versión pdfProtocolo Facultativo de la Convención sobre la Eliminación de todas las Formas de Discriminación contra la MujerConvención contra la tortura y otros tratos o penas crueles, inhumanos o degradantesversión pdfProtocolo Facultativo de la Convención sobre los Derechos de las Personas con DiscapacidadEl ACNUR recibe con beneplácito el envío de tropas de la OTAN a Kosovo y se prepara ante una posible llegada de refugiados a Serbia.Kosovo.- El jefe de la Minuk denuncia que los serbios boicotearon las legislativas por 'presiones'.Bosnia and Herzegovina. Population.Datos básicos de Montenegro, historia y evolución política.Serbia y Montenegro. Indicador: Tasa global de fecundidad (por 1000 habitantes).Serbia y Montenegro. Indicador: Tasa bruta de mortalidad (por 1000 habitantes).Population.Falleció el patriarca de la Iglesia Ortodoxa serbia.Atacan en Kosovo autobuses con peregrinos tras la investidura del patriarca serbio IrinejSerbian in Hungary.Tasas de cambio."Kosovo es de todos sus ciudadanos".Report for Serbia.Country groups by income.GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT (GDP) OF THE REPUBLIC OF SERBIA 1997–2007.Economic Trends in the Republic of Serbia 2006.National Accounts Statitics.Саопштења за јавност.GDP per inhabitant varied by one to six across the EU27 Member States.Un pacto de estabilidad para Serbia.Unemployment rate rises in Serbia.Serbia, Belarus agree free trade to woo investors.Serbia, Turkey call investors to Serbia.Success Stories.U.S. Private Investment in Serbia and Montenegro.Positive trend.Banks in Serbia.La Cámara de Comercio acompaña a empresas madrileñas a Serbia y Croacia.Serbia Industries.Energy and mining.Agriculture.Late crops, fruit and grapes output, 2008.Rebranding Serbia: A Hobby Shortly to Become a Full-Time Job.Final data on livestock statistics, 2008.Serbian cell-phone users.U Srbiji sve više računara.Телекомуникације.U Srbiji 27 odsto gradjana koristi Internet.Serbia and Montenegro.Тренд гледаности програма РТС-а у 2008. и 2009.години.Serbian railways.General Terms.El mercado del transporte aéreo en Serbia.Statistics.Vehículos de motor registrados.Planes ambiciosos para el transporte fluvial.Turismo.Turistički promet u Republici Srbiji u periodu januar-novembar 2007. godine.Your Guide to Culture.Novi Sad - city of culture.Nis - european crossroads.Serbia. Properties inscribed on the World Heritage List .Stari Ras and Sopoćani.Studenica Monastery.Medieval Monuments in Kosovo.Gamzigrad-Romuliana, Palace of Galerius.Skiing and snowboarding in Kopaonik.Tara.New7Wonders of Nature Finalists.Pilgrimage of Saint Sava.Exit Festival: Best european festival.Banje u Srbiji.«The Encyclopedia of world history»Culture.Centenario del arte serbio.«Djordje Andrejevic Kun: el único pintor de los brigadistas yugoslavos de la guerra civil española»About the museum.The collections.Miroslav Gospel – Manuscript from 1180.Historicity in the Serbo-Croatian Heroic Epic.Culture and Sport.Conversación con el rector del Seminario San Sava.'Reina Margot' funde drama, historia y gesto con música de Goran Bregovic.Serbia gana Eurovisión y España decepciona de nuevo con un vigésimo puesto.Home.Story.Emir Kusturica.Tercer oro para Paskaljevic.Nikola Tesla Year.Home.Tesla, un genio tomado por loco.Aniversario de la muerte de Nikola Tesla.El Museo Nikola Tesla en Belgrado.El inventor del mundo actual.República de Serbia.University of Belgrade official statistics.University of Novi Sad.University of Kragujevac.University of Nis.Comida. Cocina serbia.Cooking.Montenegro se convertirá en el miembro 204 del movimiento olímpico.España, campeona de Europa de baloncesto.El Partizan de Belgrado se corona campeón por octava vez consecutiva.Serbia se clasifica para el Mundial de 2010 de Sudáfrica.Serbia Name Squad For Northern Ireland And South Korea Tests.Fútbol.- El Partizán de Belgrado se proclama campeón de la Liga serbia.Clasificacion final Mundial de balonmano Croacia 2009.Serbia vence a España y se consagra campeón mundial de waterpolo.Novak Djokovic no convence pero gana en Australia.Gana Ana Ivanovic el Roland Garros.Serena Williams gana el US Open por tercera vez.Biography.Bradt Travel Guide SerbiaThe Encyclopedia of World War IGobierno de SerbiaPortal del Gobierno de SerbiaPresidencia de SerbiaAsamblea Nacional SerbiaMinisterio de Asuntos exteriores de SerbiaBanco Nacional de SerbiaAgencia Serbia para la Promoción de la Inversión y la ExportaciónOficina de Estadísticas de SerbiaCIA. Factbook 2008Organización nacional de turismo de SerbiaDiscover SerbiaConoce SerbiaNoticias de SerbiaSerbiaWorldCat1512028760000 0000 9526 67094054598-2n8519591900570825ge1309191004530741010url17413117006669D055771Serbia